15 Thanksgiving Pie Recipes for Dessert (2026 Guide)

Want to get more out of thanksgiving pie recipes dessert without the guesswork? Below we walk through the essentials in plain language, with practical steps you can use right away.

Key Takeaways

• Thanksgiving Pie Recipes for Dessert will delight all your Thanksgiving guests!
• These delicious pie recipes for Thanksgiving are delicious!
• RELATED:  25 Fall Dessert Recipes Without Pumpkin Have you started thinking about your Thanksgiving meal?
• The whipped topping also incorporates the Irish Cream to add some more flavor to this Pumpkin Pie!

How Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Dessert Really Works

I have rounded up some of the best Thanksgiving Pie Recipes for Dessert so you can decide what pie recipes for Thanksgiving you may wish to make. Worth noting: 15 Pie Recipes for Thanksgiving Dessert 1.) Straightforward Pumpkin Crumb Pie from Tastes of Lizzy T Made with a traditional pumpkin pie base and a cake mix to add some simplicity, this pie is delicious and straightforward.  Top it with nut crunch streusel and cool whip for the sweet taste you love!

• 2.) Irish Cream Pumpkin Pie Recipe from Snappy Gourmet For an straightforward twist on a traditional pumpkin pie this recipe substitutes Salted Caramel Irish Cream for evaporated milk.
• 3.) Gluten Free Fudge Pecan Pie from What the Fork By applying a Gluten Free Pie Crust this pie can be served to anyone with Gluten sensitivities!
• More importantly, plus, it contains chocolate so if someone MUST have chocolate this is a excellent method to make a traditional Thanksgiving pie by adding some chocolate for them to enjoy!

Getting the Most From Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Dessert

4.) Pumpkin Meringue Pie from Dinner at the Zoo This pumpkin pie recipe is made with cream rather than evaporated milk and a store bought pie crust. If you wish you can consistently make your own homemade pie crust!

• You will require a torch to brown the outside of the meringue and a candy thermometer when making the meringue.
• Remember that 5.) Homemade Apple Pie made with Fresh Apples from Passion for Savings This pie is truly homemade and fun to make.
• Just this week I made an Apple Pie with my daughter for a school project and we had so much fun!

Tips That Make a Difference

Let your kids assist with the straightforward parts of this recipe, they’ll be so proud! 6.) Amish Oatmeal Pie Recipe from A Taste of Lizzy T During the Civil War pecans were in short supply in the South so they substituted oats for pecans and that is where Oatmeal Pie was created!

• As a rule, if you don’t care for Pecan Pie this is a excellent alternative to try!
• 7.) Butterscotch Pie from Saving Room for Dessert This pie resembles a pumpkin pie by looks, but is filled with butterscotch filling.  If you don’t care for pumpkin pie this is another excellent alternative for a Thanksgiving pie.
• You can also get a pie crust recipe here too if you’re after one!

Common Mistakes to Avoid

8.) Pear Pie with Cheddar Crust from Food Done Light This pie has been modified to contain less calories from an original version, so it might be worth a try if you don’t wish to go overboard on calories with your pie this Thanksgiving! In short, i personally can’t wait to try this one.

• I love pears and the cheddar crust sounds impressive too!
• 9.) Sweet Potato Pie with Maple Whipped Cream from Little Sweet Baker For more texture and richness try sweet potato pie rather than pumpkin pie this year.
• You’ll also notice that sweet potato pie is more dense than a pumpkin pie.

Is Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Dessert Worth It?

Worth noting: generally speaking if you like one, you’ll like the other too! 10.) Apple Pecan Pie from Food Done Light By Combining the traditional Apple Pie and the traditional Pecan Pie into one, this might be a new family  favorite this Thanksgiving!

• 11.) Rustic Apple Blackberry Pie from Cook with Kushi If you’re after a pie crust made from scratch and a blackberry and apple pie filling this is your pie recipe!
• I love the addition of the blackberries for a little different twist on a regular apple pie!
• More importantly, 12.) Rhubarb Pie from A Side of Sweet I grew up with a garden my father and grandfather planted together and recall consistently having fresh rhubarb.

Where the Real Savings Hide

As a kid I didn’t like it, but I’ve grown to love more flavors as I’ve gotten wiser! It was consistently a pie request from our two gardeners to have a rhubarb pie for Thanksgiving!

• Here’s a recipe for you to try if you have access to Rhubarb!
• Remember that 13.)  Cherry Pie from Marsha’s Baking Addiction My Dad likes cherry pie, so this pie came to my mind when I was thinking about pies to make for Thanksgiving.
• This recipe also includes a homemade pie crust recipe if you wish to make your own crust!

A Closer Look at Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Dessert

14.) Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie from Pie Lady Bakes If you have some chocolate fans attending your Thanksgiving meal then you might wish to try this impressive pie recipe! It’s a excellent addition to some more traditional Thanksgiving pie recipes for our chocolate loving friends!

• As a rule, 15.) Cranberry Apple Pie from Liz on Call Cranberries and Apples just seem to call out the fruits we know to be sought after for Fall!
• You can’t have Thanksgiving without some kind of cranberry, so this is a solid method to add it to your meal!
• Don’t forget to Pin your favorite Thanksgiving Pie Recipes for Dessert!

What to Know About Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Dessert

READ NEXT: Thanksgiving Appetizer Recipes.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I save money on thanksgiving pie recipes dessert?

Compare prices across a few retailers, look for active coupon codes, and time bigger buys around sales events. Worth noting: 15 Pie Recipes for Thanksgiving Dessert 1.) Straightforward Pumpkin Crumb Pie from Tastes of Lizzy T Made with a traditional pumpkin pie base and a cake mix to add some simplicity, this pie is delicious and....

Is it worth shopping around for thanksgiving pie recipes dessert?

Usually yes. 2.) Irish Cream Pumpkin Pie Recipe from Snappy Gourmet For an straightforward twist on a traditional pumpkin pie this recipe substitutes Salted Caramel Irish Cream for evaporated milk.

What should I check before buying?

Read the terms, confirm any code still works, and factor in shipping or returns. 3.) Gluten Free Fudge Pecan Pie from What the Fork By applying a Gluten Free Pie Crust this pie can be served to anyone with Gluten sensitivities!.

Smart Ways to Save More on Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Dessert

• Pair cashback with a coupon so you save twice on the same order.
• Stack a coupon code with an existing sale whenever the store allows it.
• Sign up for the retailer newsletter to catch first time and seasonal discounts.
• Compare the final price including shipping, not just the headline number.
• Check for student, military, or first order offers you may qualify for.

Final Thoughts

The bottom line on thanksgiving pie recipes dessert: a little research goes a long way. Compare your options, watch for seasonal offers, and never pay full price when a better deal is a click away.

Originally published at passionforsavings.com.