Homemade Creamy Butter Mints (2026 Guide)

Want to get more out of homemade creamy butter mints without the guesswork? Below we walk through the essentials in plain language, with practical steps you can use right away.

Key Takeaways

• A cream cheese and butter mint that is melt-in-your-mouth delicious.
• It is so straightforward to make butter mints and once you make them you will wish them for each occasion throughout the year.
• Butter mints are traditionally served at weddings, baby showers, and the holidays.
• Grab any color of food coloring and create mints that match any themed event.

Is Homemade Creamy Butter Mints Worth It?

Worth noting: pair your mints next to my Christmas tree meringue cookies for another reveal-stopping treat. Or try these candy cane reindeer treats!

• Reasons You Will Love These Holiday Butter Mints Budget-friendly mints to make for the holiday season.
• This is an old-fashioned butter mint recipe that is tried and true.
• More importantly, a nice smooth mint flavor in each of the butter mints.
• A excellent make-ahead after-dinner mint recipe to keep on hand.

Where the Real Savings Hide

Ingredients Cream Cheese - Be sure to apply softened cream cheese so it will mix well with the other ingredients. Butter - Unsalted butter is what I recommend.

• Remember that if you apply salted butter it can be overpowering.
• Mint Extract - Apply mint extract to add that smooth minty flavor to the butter mints.
• Powdered Sugar - Powdered sugar is going to provide you that ultra-velvety texture.
• Food Coloring - I used red and green food coloring for this recipe to make it Christmas-themed.

A Closer Look at Homemade Creamy Butter Mints

As a rule, but feel free to apply any colors you would like. How to Make Buttermints Full steps on how to make these Creamy Buttermints are in the printable recipe card.

• This is a quick walk-through on how it is made.
• Step 1: Line your cutting board or tray with parchment paper.
• In short, then sprinkle with a layer of powdered sugar.
• Step 2: In a bowl, you will add your cream cheese and butter and mix well.

What to Know About Homemade Creamy Butter Mints

Be sure to scrape down the sides. Step 3: Slowly work in the powdered sugar.

• Worth noting: be sure as you are mixing you scrape sides and bottom of the bowl.
• Step 4: Add in the mint extract to fully mix.
• Step 5: Divide dough into 3 pieces and add food coloring to each.
• Step 6: Then once chilled you will shape the mints and dust them with powdered sugar.

How Homemade Creamy Butter Mints Really Works

More importantly, step 7: Return the shaped mints to the fridge, to set up. Then serve and enjoy.

• Are butter mints the same as after-dinner mints?
• After dinner mints and butter mints are sometimes used as the same, but they are not the same.
• Remember that butter mints are made with butter and are a more melt-in-your-mouth consistency.
• After dinner mints can be made with other ingredients and while they both are mints, the texture varies.

Getting the Most From Homemade Creamy Butter Mints

How do I adjust the mint flavor in butter mints? Begin by adding less extract to the dough.

• As a rule, then taste and if you wish a stronger mint flavor then you can add more mint extract.
• Adjust the flavor as you would like to reach your desired mint flavor.
• Pointers for Making Applying powdered sugar to create a nonstick surface is a must.
• Otherwise, the mints will stick together.

Tips That Make a Difference

In short, applying a hand or stand mixer is going to assist get that added velvety smooth texture to the mints. Roll the dough and then cut into the shape you wish.

• Work in sections of the dough so it is easier to handle.
• Allow time for the mints to set up before serving.
• Worth noting: otherwise, the texture will be off.
• You can apply any color of food coloring to create mints that fit your specific look.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I save money on homemade creamy butter mints?

Compare prices across a few retailers, look for active coupon codes, and time bigger buys around sales events. Or try these candy cane reindeer treats!.

Is it worth shopping around for homemade creamy butter mints?

Usually yes. Reasons You Will Love These Holiday Butter Mints Budget-friendly mints to make for the holiday season.

What should I check before buying?

Read the terms, confirm any code still works, and factor in shipping or returns. This is an old-fashioned butter mint recipe that is tried and true.

Smart Ways to Save More on Homemade Creamy Butter Mints

• Compare the final price including shipping, not just the headline number.
• Check for student, military, or first order offers you may qualify for.
• Time non urgent purchases around major sale events for the deepest cuts.
• Leave items in your cart for a day; some stores send a follow up discount.
• Pair cashback with a coupon so you save twice on the same order.

Final Thoughts

The bottom line on homemade creamy butter mints: a little research goes a long way. Compare your options, watch for seasonal offers, and never pay full price when a better deal is a click away.

Originally published at savingdollarsandsense.com.